Merge Digital Dot Com Merge Digital Dot Com
Merge Digital Dot Com Eats & Drinks Merge Digital Dot Com Movies Merge Digital Dot Com Music Merge Digital Dot Com Arts Merge Digital Dot Com Your Stuff Merge Digital Dot Com Other Stuff Merge Digital Dot Com Photos Merge Digital Dot Com Search Merge Digital Dot Com
Post Calendar: February 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28      
Merge Digital
• TV Watchers
• Valley Events  
Merge Digital
• TV Watchers Has Moved!!!!


• The Ticking Time Bomb

• On an Island of Mystery

• The Final Five

• VIDEO: When Aqua Teen and 24 Collide...

• Wedding Crasher

• Wheels Within Wheels...

• Lost: Are You My Father?

• A Clockwork Lost

Merge Digital
•  Prison Break - Ridiculous But Awesome

•  Prison Break - Ridiculous But Awesome

•  Rockstar: Supernova

•  Deal...or No Deal?

•  Deal...or No Deal?

•  Deal...or No Deal?

•  Deal...or No Deal?

•  It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia

•  DVR = Late Nights

•  DVR = Late Nights

Merge Digital
• February 2007

• January 2007

• December 2006

• November 2006

• October 2006

• September 2006

• August 2006

• July 2006

• June 2006

• May 2006

• View Complete Archive List

• Subscribe to this blog's feed
Blog: TV Watchers
« A Clockwork Lost | Main | Wheels Within Wheels... »
Lost: Are You My Father?
Posted by Tucker Hottes at 09:54:33 AM on February 8, 2007
Total Comments: 0

Awesome episode last night, great recap Tom. I won't bother covering the same ground, but yeah - that Clockwork Orange scene might have actually been more disturbing than the scene in Clockwork Orange itself.  Or maybe that's just how crazy scary it was in HD. I dunno.

Anyway, here's the only thing that bugged me about last night's episode, and honestly I tossed and turned last night until I came up with a plausible solution. Seriously, I have trouble sleeping thinking about these things. I know, it's sad. Don't judge me.

So they made it pretty clear that Alex was referring to Ben when she kept talking about "my father." I didn't like that one bit, and here's an attempt to logically lay out why:

-Unless something's been retconned (or just wasn't correct in the first place), Rousseau is Alex's mother
-Rousseau claimed her baby, Alex, was fathered by her lover, Robert
-Ben looks way younger than Rousseau, and besides thinking about them hooking up is creepy
-Rousseau also claimed she was seven months pregnant when they landed
-Ben claims he's lived on the island his whole life

I could keep going on, but it just doesn't make any sense for Ben to be shacking up with Rousseau and fathering our favorite rebel Other. I was actually kind of mad about it for a while, and like I said - I couldn't stop mulling it over.

Then, in the shower this morning, it came to me: Ben/the Others stole Alex as a baby. Duh. They could tell her Zeus is her father if they wanted to. Honestly, that's the only thing that can reconcile this for me - and the more I think about it, the more it's got to be the case.

Maybe it was clear for other people, and I'm not sure why I didn't think of Ben lying in the first place, but it did bother me for a while.  Anyway, mostly I'm just glad Lost is back.


  Comment on this entry. View any comments on this entry. Syndicate This Blog

Current Comments

Post A Comment

The comments to this entry have been closed.